Re: UNI post-game thoughts.
Originally Posted by
td577
I agree with a lot of what you are saying but there are a couple of different dynamics you are missing here. While I will not condone any one of these student/athletes being berated, criticism does go with the game. They are adults now and made a decision to make their participation in athletics part of their education experience. That experience is incredible. There are not many situations a college age person can put themselves where they subject themselves to such a high level of pressure to perform on both the field and in the classroom where their life isn't on the line or business failure an end result. I have endlessly applauded their efforts in taking advantage of these learning opportunities and it comes with people being critical of their performance. There are a lot of student/athletes benefitting from the generosity of those paying for their education and they do want to be entertained. Is it 100% right? Probably not, but I don't think it is 100% wrong either. There should be a balance where their participation is recognized as part of the education process, the criticism should reflect that, and the investment made by Bison boosters and fans should also be balanced towards the enrichment extra curricular activities bring the institution and not merely the entertainment value having a pseudo minor league football team some believe we have. I think there have been some student/athletes who can't handle the pressure and have made other choices. I do think there have been many others who have embraced the challenge and handle the pressure with maturity and value the learning experience. I do not think any student/athlete deserves to be called out on the carpet for anything as they are not professionals and they are still learning their craft. I do think most people here can responsibly criticize without berating. We are still talking about adults, making adult decisions, with adult consequences, and going into the decision knowing there are expectations. When individuals have been berated, it has been handled pretty well here. Criticism is part of the process.
I agree 100% you hit the nail on the head better than I did.
From the movie THE PROGRAM
Regent Chairman: This is not a football vocational school. It's an institute for higher learning.
Coach Winters: Yeah, but when was the last time 80,000 people showed up to watch a kid do a damn chemistry experiment? Why don't you stick the bow-tie up your ass?