Transfer Portal

[G_Funky]

Lets see how everyone likes it when the middle to bottom half of the P5 starts getting gutted. See how happy PJ Fleck is when Ohio State takes his 2 best players every year. Or when Georgia takes K-States starting QB. It's not going to end well. The G5 schools will get gutted. You will see practice squads that would be a solid G5 team

Adapt or die.

[NDSU92]

Lets see how everyone likes it when the middle to bottom half of the P5 starts getting gutted. See how happy PJ Fleck is when Ohio State takes his 2 best players every year. Or when Georgia takes K-States starting QB. It's not going to end well. The G5 schools will get gutted. You will see practice squads that would be a solid G5 team

It is what it is. They tried to make it a business while calling it amateurism as long as they could. Unless people come to the realization that they're paying a bunch of 18-20 year olds a ridiculous amount of money to go try and put a ball across a line on a field we'll be stuck. Just sad. When you think about all of the money and time that gets spent on college sports these days you come to realize what a waste it all is. Long gone are the days of just driving down to the stadium, paying $10 to watch a game for 3 hours and getting on with your life. The kids, administrators, coaches, fans, etc. spend all this time for a ball to go through a hoop or cross a goal line lol. I think these recent changes are starting to have folks like me realize how ridiculous it has all gotten.

College athletics is an interesting topic to argue about though. Most topics these day are so binary (yes/no, blue/red, etc.) that the spectrum on this is overwhelming. I can make the argument that schools shouldn't be allowed to actively recruit high schoolers while I also make the argument that kids should get paid as much as people are willing to pay. And every single fan will have a different opinion somewhere on the spectrum between.

[bisonaudit]

It is what it is. They tried to make it a business while calling it amateurism as long as they could. Unless people come to the realization that they're paying a bunch of 18-20 year olds a ridiculous amount of money to go try and put a ball across a line on a field we'll be stuck. Just sad. When you think about all of the money and time that gets spent on college sports these days you come to realize what a waste it all is. Long gone are the days of just driving down to the stadium, paying $10 to watch a game for 3 hours and getting on with your life. The kids, administrators, coaches, fans, etc. spend all this time for a ball to go through a hoop or cross a goal line lol. I think these recent changes are starting to have folks like me realize how ridiculous it has all gotten.

College athletics is an interesting topic to argue about though. Most topics these day are so binary (yes/no, blue/red, etc.) that the spectrum on this is overwhelming. I can make the argument that schools shouldn't be allowed to actively recruit high schoolers while I also make the argument that kids should get paid as much as people are willing to pay. And every single fan will have a different opinion somewhere on the spectrum between.

I think most issues are like that they just get reduced to false binaries by slingers of bullshit with to many hours to fill.

You would think that 24 networks for news sports or whatever would actually encourage depth, subtlety and nuanced takes. Turns out they’re just the same 30 minute Sesame Street episode played on a loop all day.

[NDSU92]

I think most issues are like that they just get reduced to false binaries by slingers of bullshit with to many hours to fill.

You would think that 24 networks for news sports or whatever would actually encourage depth, subtlety and nuanced takes. Turns out they’re just the same 30 minute Sesame Street episode played on a loop all day.

Very fair points. Definitely agree.

[The_Sicatoka]

I think these recent changes are starting to have folks like me realize how ridiculous it has all gotten.

We can hope.

[The_Sicatoka]

You would think that 24 networks for news sports or whatever would actually encourage depth, subtlety and nuanced takes.

You used a word that no longer happens.

Don Henley warned us 40+ years ago ... "see the bubble-headed bleach blonde that comes on at five ... "

[Hammerhead]

It's been ridiculous for a long time with the arms race on which schools can build the best athlete lounges, locker rooms, practice facilities, ect.

All kinds of entertainers get paid large sums of money to play sports, appear in movies/TV, or perform in concert because there is a big demand and a small supply of top-notch talent. I just wonder how long some donors will keep giving to collectives if all they get in return is a 7-4 season and a lower tier bowl game.

[WhoRepsTheLurker]

It's been ridiculous for a long time with the arms race on which schools can build the best athlete lounges, locker rooms, practice facilities, ect.

All kinds of entertainers get paid large sums of money to play sports, appear in movies/TV, or perform in concert because there is a big demand and a small supply of top-notch talent. I just wonder how long some donors will keep giving to collectives if all they get in return is a 7-4 season and a lower tier bowl game.

Interesting way to phrase it. I donate to NDSU athletics not to 'get' something, but to give something, because I want to see it continue to grow and succeed, and where the last word has a myriad of definitions (only one of which involves playing another FCS team in Frisco TX)

[HerdBot]

It's been ridiculous for a long time with the arms race on which schools can build the best athlete lounges, locker rooms, practice facilities, ect.

All kinds of entertainers get paid large sums of money to play sports, appear in movies/TV, or perform in concert because there is a big demand and a small supply of top-notch talent. I just wonder how long some donors will keep giving to collectives if all they get in return is a 7-4 season and a lower tier bowl game.

At least the arms race is typically privately funded. I dont actually have a problem with NIL if there are limits and oversight. Unfortunately its gone from letting a star QB do a TV commercial to paying everyone for merely existing. With that being said, we have to do it to be competitive. Sad but true

[SDbison]

At least the arms race is typically privately funded. I dont actually have a problem with NIL if there are limits and oversight. Unfortunately its gone from letting a star QB do a TV commercial to paying everyone for merely existing. With that being said, we have to do it to be competitive. Sad but true

. There is a simple solution. Ban collectives. Also require that if a student athlete is paid for NIL services the payment has to be reasonable (I know good luck with that). At least, no payment allowed unless some service, outside of playing their game, is provided.