Based SOLELY on their career performance with the Bison. Not entirely based on stats. Many might be based on emotion/memory.
Stick (Jensen with a better arm)
Jensen (Had the will to win)
Wentz (Rode the bench even though he was arguably more gifted than Jensen)
Walker (Kinda set us on the path to success even though he was never playoff eligible, he was FUN to watch though)
Lance (Had he put in 2 full years+ as a starter I'd probably have him listed higher, probably the best QB of the bunch overall)
Strauss
Mertens
Gorder
Noland (possibly a great leader, but not a great QB)
Mohler (was never a Jose fan, I liked him less than I like Zeb)