The Cutting Edge - Who Would You Pick?

[tony]

Unfortunately for Carson in this scenario, he's on the sideline with his arm in a sling, his knee in a brace and his thumb in a cast. Being able to stay healthy is a big part of being successful in sports. All things considered I'm taking the guy with three championship rings as starter.

Well, Carson has 3 championship rings... it's just that one is a Super Bowl ring.

[MankatoBison]

First of all, we win the game in every single scenario.

1. Jensen
2. Walker
3. Wentz
4. Stick

Stick is only 4th because he had the fewest chances to demonstrate the come from behind mentality. Normally, he scrapped and scraped his ass off during the first 3 qtrs so we basically NEVER had to have a last minute drive. He showed it at IOWA in a BIG TIME game. so all indications show that he is completely effective in this, but I have to go with the other 3 simply on the premise that they HAD to do this multiple times and all three were MAGIC in those situations

[Bisonator98]

This is a non debate. WTF even discuss it? Oh well....

The correct answer is Carson Wentz. Guy can beat you with his legs and his arm. Go back and rewatch the last 2 minutes of the 2015 UNI game and tell me Brock or Easton could have made some of those out throws to RJ or Vraa. Not happening, I'm sorry but those guys do not have the same arm talent, it's a fact.

[EC8CH]

This is a non debate. WTF even discuss it? Oh well....

The correct answer is Carson Wentz. Guy can beat you with his legs and his arm. Go back and rewatch the last 2 minutes of the 2015 UNI game and tell me Brock or Easton could have made some of those out throws to RJ or Vraa. Not happening, I'm sorry but those guys do not have the same arm talent, it's a fact.

That's why I just posted that comeback drive. 1:45 left, no timeouts, down 4 on their own 20 something, 4th and 7. Wentz drove down the field passing the entire way and left 35 seconds on the clock. Stick or Jensen could not do that. Period, end of discussion. Maybe they pull off a win a different way, but I doubt it. I'm a firm believe that without Wentz as QB for that drive, there is no way the Bison win that game. He was cutting up the UNI secondary like a thanksgiving day turkey.

[Bison 4 Life]

Except for the fact that Wentz ACTUALLY DID what was asked in the hypothetical question.....so it is Wentz

I'm surprised that no one seemed to mention this before now. That's exactly what I thought myself.

[Bisonator98]

That's why I just posted that comeback drive. 1:45 left, no timeouts, down 4 on their own 20 something, 4th and 7. Wentz drove down the field passing the entire way and left 35 seconds on the clock. Stick or Jensen could not do that. Period, end of discussion. Maybe they pull off a win a different way, but I doubt it. I'm a firm believe that without Wentz as QB for that drive, there is no way the Bison win that game. He was cutting up the UNI secondary like a thanksgiving day turkey.

Yeah I posted before finishing the thread. Exactly right!

[MankatoBison]

First of all, we win the game in every single scenario.

1. Jensen
2. Walker
3. Wentz
4. Stick

Stick is only 4th because he had the fewest chances to demonstrate the come from behind mentality. Normally, he scrapped and scraped his ass off during the first 3 qtrs so we basically NEVER had to have a last minute drive. He showed it at IOWA in a BIG TIME game. so all indications show that he is completely effective in this, but I have to go with the other 3 simply on the premise that they HAD to do this multiple times and all three were MAGIC in those situations

I watched the UNI ending again... and I have to eat crow. Strike my previous list from the record entirely.

1. Wentz - in 1:45 you have to have the biggest, most accurate arm. Wentz is that guy
2. WALKER - Gunslinger- nuff said. Ice in his veins
3. Jensen - If we start the 4th quarter down- I take Jensen over all the others honestly. Even though walker has an exemplary 4th qtr comeback resume. Lets face it, they all have virtually perfect 4th quarter resumes.
4. Stick - same reason I stated abo

[WeAreThePride]

Well, Carson has 3 championship rings... it's just that one is a Super Bowl ring.

For which he was injured...

[EC8CH]

I watched the UNI ending again... and I have to eat crow. Strike my previous list from the record entirely.

1. Wentz - in 1:45 you have to have the biggest, most accurate arm. Wentz is that guy
2. WALKER - Gunslinger- nuff said. Ice in his veins
3. Jensen - If we start the 4th quarter down- I take Jensen over all the others honestly. Even though walker has an exemplary 4th qtr comeback resume. Lets face it, they all have virtually perfect 4th quarter resumes.
4. Stick - same reason I stated abo

This is a solid ranking with excellent reasoning. Under different scenarios I could see a different ranking, but with 1:45 left down 4 on your own 20... these are the traits you're looking for in a QB to lead the required comeback.

[bri-dog]

I don't like to live in the past. So I'm going with Trey Lance and Christian Watson.