Committee Rankings

[Bison56]

Didn't you hear? They are the real dynasty

Yeah they are officially more delusional than JSU fans.

[bisonaudit]

Central Arkansas in a bye position is my biggest issue with this ranking, Montana should be seeded instead. Followed by UNH appearing at all, they’re probably the 4th best team in the CAA. The rest of it isn’t bad.

[stevdock]

I am curious where you think they should be? (And this is meant in an honest, non-asshole way.) I could see swapping them with Weber State (which may happen by the end of the year), but I don't know if I would bump them below SDSU.... I mean they still are undefeated in the FCS and playing from a "power conference".

I think you could make a logical argument for SDSU to be 3 and JMU to be 4. I've said many times over the last 8 years that teams that play us should almost look at that as an FBS game. I know we're not FBS, but I don't know if a team should be punished for that, especially when it comes down to 1 play. SDSU's two losses are against teams that haven't lost yet, where as JMU's loss was to a 3-5 team. If SDSU wins out and JMU wins out I think SDSU would then have the better resume and could jump JMU. It won't happen as the committee will not open themselves up to that, but the argument could be made.

[tjbison]

I think you could make a logical argument for SDSU to be 3 and JMU to be 4. I've said many times over the last 8 years that teams that play us should almost look at that as an FBS game. I know we're not FBS, but I don't know if a team should be punished for that, especially when it comes down to 1 play. SDSU's two losses are against teams that haven't lost yet, where as JMU's loss was to a 3-5 team. If SDSU wins out and JMU wins out I think SDSU would then have the better resume and could jump JMU. It won't happen as the committee will not open themselves up to that, but the argument could be made.

SDSU also has their best win as SIU, they need to beat ISU-R and UNI

[X-Factor]

SDSU also has their best win as SIU, they need to beat ISU-R and UNI

Yahtzee. SDSU wins to date are very pedestrian and JMU has the better resume from a win column standpoint. Quality losses? Sure, give the funnies the trophy for that

The next few weeks in funny land will make/break their season and only then can we talk about them over JMU. I fully expect them to beat ISUr, UNI could be a tough one.

[EC8CH]

Yahtzee. SDSU wins to date are very pedestrian and JMU has the better resume from a win column standpoint. Quality losses? Sure, give the funnies the trophy for that

The next few weeks in funny land will make/break their season and only then can we talk about them over JMU. I fully expect them to beat ISUr, UNI could be a tough one.

I agree that if the Bunnies win out they should be ranked ahead of JMU, but I doubt the committee would do the right thing.

[Mr Pep Band]

I really hope NH beats JMU. Puts them in their place and bumps up SDSU to where they belong, 2 seed, maybe the 3 seed at worst if they win out.

It isn't going to happen, but its nice to dream.