The schools are responsible for implementing/enforcing the regs. If they're out of compliance, they deal directly with fed OCR...theoretically, there can be consequences, but OCR usually works with the school to bring things into compliance and rarely pulls any funds from the school..
I wonder how well that would work. There are so many administrative and governance things handled through the NCAA and shared among all members. They would have to do that on their and duplicate something already done. One simple thing is the game rules. These are all NCAA. Would they create their own rule books? They could do like NAIA and Texas HS and just adopt the NCAA playing rules, but they have no say in the creation or update of the rules.
I don't ever see a complete separation from the NCAA. It's more likely to be a carved out part of the NCAA for the areas they truly are different. Not unlike CFP. It is a separate organization but it exists for one purpose. Yes they have huge amounts of revenue, but they also have huge expenses. I would be very curious to see how the men's basketball media deal would be handled. Would this new organization own that contract and get all the revenue? Would they have to share it with the NCAA if they allowed some of their members to participate? Would any changes in this space increase or decrease the broadcast rights. You would end up paying a lot of lawyers and consultants a lot of money to figure out all those logistics.
The obvious reaction is ... "that will never happen". But with the dollars involved mixed in with human greed, well never say never.
Title IX is Federal law. It follows wherever.
"Sometimes a concept is baffling not because it is profound but because it is wrong" E. O. Wilson
"I'm not crazy my mother had me tested". Sheldon Cooper
My boss hates it when I shorten his name to Dick, mainly because his name is Steven.