Carson Wentz

[JMB]

Childress weighs in on Carson
http://www.nj.com/eagles/index.ssf/2...l_quarter.html

To Max Kellerman I say "Judging any rookie on half a game of play, in what universe is that not bad sports analysis?"

Obviously it is too early to judge this, but what kind of career dies Carson need to have for this to be a "good" trade?

[bisonsupporter]

Obviously it is too early to judge this, but what kind of career dies Carson need to have for this to be a "good" trade?

Joe Flaaco type of career?

[bisonaudit]

Kellerman is right. I was a shitty trade. That's not the same thing as saying Wentz isn't going to be a good NFL QB.

[bisonaudit]

Obviously it is too early to judge this, but what kind of career dies Carson need to have for this to be a "good" trade?

It's not too early to judge the trade. It was dumb. Waiting to see how good Carson turns out to be is not the proper yard stick for evaluating the transaction.

Even if it were Joe Flaco wouldn't be the right answer. You'd better look higher on the list.

[bisonsupporter]

Kellerman is right. I was a shitty trade. That's not the same thing as saying Wentz isn't going to be a good NFL QB.

Completely agree the trade was over the top for a draft class that on paper, may only have a few "players" out of all 256.

[Hammerhead]

Probably won't know for 3 or 4 years to really know if most NFL QBs are really good. The FCS is not D-II and the top 3 or 4 conferences are really G5 conferences with 22 fewer scholarships.

[JMB]

It's not too early to judge the trade. It was dumb. Waiting to see how good Carson turns out to be is not the proper yard stick for evaluating the transaction.

Even if it were Joe Flaco wouldn't be the right answer. You'd better look higher on the list.

I would like to change my answer solely on the fact I found myself agreeing with Stephen A. Smith.

[pucknut9]

I would like to change my answer solely on the fact I found myself agreeing with Stephen A. Smith.

Me too. Didn't think that would ever happen.

[natstar1]

Read a post on another thread when the Eagles first made the trade that I thought was good. Basically said you only make that trade for an Andrew Luck type prospect and that prospect isn't in the draft.

[MrSnuffleupagus]

I don't want to be a buzzkill...but is it officially time yet to move this thread out of the NDSU football section? Yeah, Wentz is God and a former Bison...but everything Wentz related is now non-NDSU football related.