Originally Posted by
td577
I think athletically he has shown he should certainly be considered in any conversation about the best QB of all time. With the intangibles it becomes more of a subjective comparison. He has shown he has ice water running through his veins, as well. He does only have a couple of 4th quarter game winning drives, which isn't his fault, because the Bison generally have been leading by the fourth quarter in all but a couple of games. As far as leading the team, he has done some things previous QBs could only dream about. He has a cannon for an arm with a quick release. He isn't quick, but he is fast. He wants to throw first, always. That is different then we have seen for a while. In comparison, Brock saw an opening and would just as soon take off. Every game he does something that demonstrates he sees things about the game at a very high level. The not throwing the ball on a designed screen when a lineman leaked out too far down field. Things like that.
It is tough to compare QB across generations. There were different styles across the years. If you take just the FCS era, we now have had three very outstanding QBs with different skill sets. Walker was the prototypical drop back QB who liked to stretch the play downfield. Brock who was a by the book WCO QB who could be a punishing runner when he took off. Now we have Wentz who is still coming into his own. His identity is being developed in front of us and it is a winner with a strong arm, fast legs, and a pass first to move the ball mentality. Walker and Jensen also had a couple of favorite receivers. Wentz favorite receiver is whoever is open. Maybe we are deeper with better hands or maybe Wentz doesn't care who catches the ball and figures if you are on the field and you are put there to catch a ball, you better catch the ball. Wentz will never catch some of these guys statistically but I think in one season he has shown the wait has been well worth it. He hasn't been asked to carry the team too much yet, but I have no doubt he has put himself in a position where if he had to there would wouldn't be any problem.