Re: SDSU Post Game Thoughts & Discussion
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jay
My thoughts...
Our staff is made up of a bunch of meatheads. Football guys.
That’s okay to have some. But you need a common sense, brain, logic smart guy.
Three plays are most egregious offenses....
1) Reverse pass inside the 10
2) Going for 2... simply zero logic for this.
3) Halfback pass
Also, please start taking a knee on endzone kickoffs. Starting from the 25 is okay.
I agree with all of this. It almost felt like we had no faith to do what we do in many of those situations.
Very odd game in that sense.
Re: SDSU Post Game Thoughts & Discussion
I still say going for the 2 point conversion was okay but I would assume that it wasn’t the numbers they needed to make it work and would kick the field goal instead.
It’s about possessions not points. Go up 12 it’s a 3 possession game assuming you hold them to the same td and field goal as if you were up 10-11.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: SDSU Post Game Thoughts & Discussion
Quote:
Originally Posted by
MinotBison
Post game interview, Entz said the O line all wanted to go for it on that 4th down.
Did he say if they all wanted to go for 2?
Re: SDSU Post Game Thoughts & Discussion
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jay
My thoughts...
Our staff is made up of a bunch of meatheads. Football guys.
That’s okay to have some. But you need a common sense, brain, logic smart guy.
Three plays are most egregious offenses....
1) Reverse pass inside the 10
2) Going for 2... simply zero logic for this.
3) Halfback pass
Also, please start taking a knee on endzone kickoffs. Starting from the 25 is okay.
I agree 100%.
Re: SDSU Post Game Thoughts & Discussion
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jay
My thoughts...
Our staff is made up of a bunch of meatheads. Football guys.
That’s okay to have some. But you need a common sense, brain, logic smart guy.
Three plays are most egregious offenses....
1) Reverse pass inside the 10
2) Going for 2... simply zero logic for this.
3) Halfback pass
Also, please start taking a knee on endzone kickoffs. Starting from the 25 is okay.
This is spot on. If these guys don't learn from mistakes, well, bad news for the Bison.
Re: SDSU Post Game Thoughts & Discussion
GameDay crew stick around to watch the game?
Re: SDSU Post Game Thoughts & Discussion
Everyone pissing on the two point conversion just listen a sec...
If you get it, they HAVE to get two TDs to beat you.
If you miss (which they did) they can now tie with a FG and TD+1. Got it. Yes, easier for them to tie. But still just tied.
If you go for one, you’re up by 11, and sure they have to get FG and TD+2 instead of +1 to tie, but you still just need a FG to help tie.
My point is being up 11 is “closer” to being up 10. You can disagree with the call (and I actually do), but saying it was idiotic and there was nothing to gain from it is WAY over the top.
Re: SDSU Post Game Thoughts & Discussion
In hindsight I think SDSU has a very, very good chance to win this if Gibbs stays in.
I also think even with Gibbs there's no way they win in the Fargo Dome.
Makes the outcome all the more important.
Re: SDSU Post Game Thoughts & Discussion
Don't get the gripes about playcalling - execution is the problem. NDSU's offense emptied an entire clip into its foot.
Re: SDSU Post Game Thoughts & Discussion
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Strategery
Everyone pissing on the two point conversion just listen
Up 11 or up 12 at that point in the game... that’s the question. You need a data/brain guy to tell you what is the best stat to do.