Re: Amy Anderson 2016 LPGA
Lexi Thompson got screwed this weekend. She'd played 12 holes of her final round before being informed that she was being penalized for hitting a 1 ft put from out of position during her round the day before. Some home viewer, who was probably short her in Vegas, made a phone call. So dumb. Golf is fixing a bunch of rules in the next year, project is already underway. They need to add this to the list. Two things. It's silly that anyone on their couch can act as a rules official. How can you go 20 hours telling her nothing? How do you not decide before the next round starts?
Re: Amy Anderson 2016 LPGA
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bisonaudit
Lexi Thompson got screwed this weekend. She'd played 12 holes of her final round before being informed that she was being penalized for hitting a 1 ft put from out of position during her round the day before. Some home viewer, who was probably short her in Vegas, made a phone call. So dumb. Golf is fixing a bunch of rules in the next year, project is already underway. They need to add this to the list. Two things. It's silly that anyone on their couch can act as a rules official. How can you go 20 hours telling her nothing? How do you not decide before the next round starts?
I saw Mike and Mike discuss this in the AM. As an golf idiot, can someone please explain to me why rules nazi's at home can dictate a tourney? It should be like any other sport when a call is miss. And for cripes sake, that was not intentional and I think even a rules official would be hard pressed to enforce that.
Re: Amy Anderson 2016 LPGA
Quote:
Originally Posted by
THEsocalledfan
I saw Mike and Mike discuss this in the AM. As an golf idiot, can someone please explain to me why rules nazi's at home can dictate a tourney? It should be like any other sport when a call is miss. And for cripes sake, that was not intentional and I think even a rules official would be hard pressed to enforce that.
This was terrible. I do not think she was doing it on purpose. It was just one of those things. The person that emailed in probably had Cheeto dust on one hand and something else in the other hand.
Re: Amy Anderson 2016 LPGA
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mr Meaty
This was terrible. I do not think she was doing it on purpose. It was just one of those things. The person that emailed in probably had Cheeto dust on one hand and something else in the other hand.
So, to be clear, does anyone know why a cheeto eating rule Nazi has any input on who wins a professional tournament? Please explain.
Re: Amy Anderson 2016 LPGA
Quote:
Originally Posted by
THEsocalledfan
So, to be clear, does anyone know why a cheeto eating rule Nazi has any input on who wins a professional tournament? Please explain.
In his mom's dark basement you get a really good picture on the plasma screen. I would have ignored the email and talked with Lexi on the side after the tourney. I don't believe she was trying to get away with anything, but only she knows that.
Re: Amy Anderson 2016 LPGA
Quote:
Originally Posted by
THEsocalledfan
So, to be clear, does anyone know why a cheeto eating rule Nazi has any input on who wins a professional tournament? Please explain.
Simply, the Rules of Golf allow it. I would imagine it was written in a time prior to 24 hour golf networks and HD TV and was not considered. But regardless, trying to compare it to another sport is ridiculous. If you knowingly commit a penalty in football, do you call it yourself? No, you wait until a referee calls it. In golf, rules are sacred.
Please note - I am offering no opinion as to whether I think the rule is correct. The only opinion I am offering is saying that it is stupid to compare golf to other sports.
Re: Amy Anderson 2016 LPGA
Quote:
Originally Posted by
PattyBison
Simply, the Rules of Golf allow it. I would imagine it was written in a time prior to 24 hour golf networks and HD TV and was not considered. But regardless, trying to compare it to another sport is ridiculous. If you knowingly commit a penalty in football, do you call it yourself? No, you wait until a referee calls it. In golf, rules are sacred.
Please note - I am offering no opinion as to whether I think the rule is correct. The only opinion I am offering is saying that it is stupid to compare golf to other sports.
I am not asking about the rule. I am asking why a cheeto eating rule Nazi has any input on if a player breaks the rules. No one has yet answered that question. and yes, it is legit to compare to other sports. So, an NBA official misses a call and the game goes wrong way. I should be able to email and get the outcome changed?
Re: Amy Anderson 2016 LPGA
Quote:
Originally Posted by
THEsocalledfan
I am not asking about the rule. I am asking why a cheeto eating rule Nazi has any input on if a player breaks the rules. No one has yet answered that question. and yes, it is legit to compare to other sports. So, an NBA official misses a call and the game goes wrong way. I should be able to email and get the outcome changed?
Can you be more specific as to what rule you don't care about? Because I was talking about the rule where it says that any spectator can report rules violations.
Re: Amy Anderson 2016 LPGA
Quote:
Originally Posted by
PattyBison
Can you be more specific as to what rule you don't care about? Because I was talking about the rule where it says that any spectator can report rules violations.
Good to know; thought the rule was only about the moving of the ball on the green. So there is a rule allowing spectators to report rules violations. You've got to be kidding me. That is nuts. And thank you for answering the question.
Re: Amy Anderson 2016 LPGA
The rule they changed was from disqualification to 2 strokes if a player signs a score card for a score lower on a hole than should have been recorded if the player was not aware if the infraction and it was called in by a TV viewer. This is basically the TV rule. As far as on the green, she was careless when marking and remarking and played from the wrong place, which is also 2 strokes.