Resolved: NDSU should start recruiting based on a geographic quota system

[El_Chapo]

​Verbals
Lincoln Gibbs, 5-11, 205, RB/FB, Langford, SD (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?37048-2017-Verbal-Lincoln-Gibbs)
Holden Hotchkiss, 6-4, 205, QB, Lakeland, FL (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?37094-2017-Verbal-Holden-Hotchkiss)
Nash Jensen, 6-3, 350, OG, Osseo, MN (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?37077-2017-Bison-Verbal-Nash-Jensen-OG-Osseo)
Phazione McClurge, 6-1, 190, S, Chicago (Mount Carmel), IL (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?37065-2017-Verbal-DB-Phazione-McClurge)
Logan McCormick, 6-3, 240, DE, Kimberly, WI (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?37078-2017-Verbal-Logan-McCormick)
Brandon Metz, 6-1, 270, DT, West Fargo, ND (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?37080-2017-Verbal-Brandon-Metz)
Tanner Sundt, 6-4, 240, DE, Farmington, MN (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?37071-2017-Verbal-Dline-Tanner-Sundt!!!)
Lane Tucker, 6-4, 240, DT, Gillette (Campbell County), WY (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?37101-2017-Verbal-Lane-Tucker)
Spencer Waege, 6-5, 230, DL, Watertown, SD (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?37022-2017-Verbal-Spencer-Waege)
Christian Watson, 6-2, 175, WR, Tampa (Plant Senior HS), FL (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?37121-2017-Verbal-Christian-Watson)
Zach Willis, 6-5, 290, OL, West Fargo, ND (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?37087-2017-Verbal-Zach-Willis)


More Info
BisoNation (http://www.bisonation.info)
NDSU on Scout.com (http://www.scout.com/college/north-dakota-state/)

Past Years
2016 Recruiting Summary (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?35495-2016-Recruiting-Summary)
2015 Recruiting Summary (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?33196-2015-Recruiting-Summary)
2014 Recruiting Summary (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?30926-2014-Recruiting-Summary)
2013 Recruiting Summary (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?26850-2013-Recruiting-Summary)
2012 Recruiting Summary (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?24154-2012-Recruiting-Summary)
2011 Recruiting Summary (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?20018-2011-Recruiting-Summary)
2010 Recruiting Summary (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?16978-2010-Recruiting-Summary)
2009 Recruiting Summary (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?14825-2009-Recruiting-Quick-Reference)
2008 Recruiting Summary (http://www.bisonville.com/forum/showthread.php?10168-2008-NDSU-Recruits)


Need more Twin Cities Kids!! losing Luke sucks, (HE WAS A TOP 10 Minnesota ranked recruit!) we always should have 8-10 kids from the Twin Cities Metro each year, PERIOD>

(Yes we get 6-10 each year from TC/Minnesota)

[southcliffbison]

Need more Twin Cities Kids!! losing Luke sucks, we always should have 8-10 kids from the Twin Cities Metro each year, PERIOD>

Really Chappie????? Coaches should have passed on Dudzik, Wentz, Heagle, Bruce Anderson, Darius Shepherd, Kuhnert, the big OL men from ND et al ......just because they're not from the minny/st. paul ? Really ???

[westnodak93bison]

Really Chappie????? Coaches should have passed on Dudzik, Wentz, Heagle, Bruce Anderson, Darius Shepherd, Kuhnert, the big OL men from ND et al ......just because they're not from the minny/st. paul ? Really ???
I think he said 8-10 per year which is a stretch. How many do we usually get from the TC?

Sent from my XT1254 using Tapatalk

[tony]

I think he said 8-10 per year which is a stretch. How many do we usually get from the TC?


3 or 4 - almost all from outside, often way outside, the 494/694 ring. Seems incredible that anybody would criticize NDSU's recruiting but you must consider the source.

Debate topic: Resolved: NDSU should start recruiting based on a geographic quota system. Debating for the affirmative: Lakesbison Rebutting: Nobody because why bother?

All one can do is move this crap to its own thread rather than mess up one that is meant to serve as a permanent reference.

[GOBISON123]

Nebraska, Kansas

[DM05]

Need more Twin Cities Kids!! losing Luke sucks, (HE WAS A TOP 10 Minnesota ranked recruit!) we always should have 8-10 kids from the Twin Cities Metro each year, PERIOD>

(Yes we get 6-10 each year from TC/Minnesota)

A top 10 Minnesota recruit that obviously doesn't want to be at NDSU and doesn't want to compete for playing time. Good luck to him, but good riddance....Give me guys that wanna work their tails off, no matter what recruiting rankings say. Give me Haeg, Schaetz, and Steidl who will put in some effort to earn a scholarship over a guy that is upset that he has competition at his position.

And the 8-10 from the cities is pretty dumb. I would rather have all the right players from places no one has heard of than take wrong ones just to have a presence in MSP.

[Trumpster]

3 or 4 - almost all from outside, often way outside, the 494/694 ring. Seems incredible that anybody would criticize NDSU's recruiting but you must consider the source.

Debate topic: Resolved: NDSU should start recruiting based on a geographic quota system. Debating for the affirmative: Lakesbison Rebutting: Nobody because why bother?

All one can do is move this crap to its own thread rather than mess up one that is meant to serve as a permanent reference.


Thank you.

[Professor Chaos]

Jose 2009-12!!!!

[OtterTailLakeBison]

A top 10 Minnesota recruit that obviously doesn't want to be at NDSU and doesn't want to compete for playing time. Good luck to him, but good riddance....Give me guys that wanna work their tails off, no matter what recruiting rankings say. Give me Haeg, Schaetz, and Steidl who will put in some effort to earn a scholarship over a guy that is upset that he has competition at his position.

And the 8-10 from the cities is pretty dumb. I would rather have all the right players from places no one has heard of than take wrong ones just to have a presence in MSP.

Great Point. It seems like El Chapo is recommending a DII recruiting model - I thought he was an FBS forward-looking evangelist. 5 championships in a row and the last 3 players drafted have been from Schuyler, NE; Bismarck, ND and Brainerd, MN.

[17>1]

3 or 4 - almost all from outside, often way outside, the 494/694 ring. Seems incredible that anybody would criticize NDSU's recruiting but you must consider the source.

Debate topic: Resolved: NDSU should start recruiting based on a geographic quota system. Debating for the affirmative: Lakesbison Rebutting: Nobody because why bother?

All one can do is move this crap to its own thread rather than mess up one that is meant to serve as a permanent reference.

Isn't Senor Chapo still on moderation? Can't you just delete or ignore the original message, so it doesn't mess anything up in the first place?

[Mr Meaty]

The recruiting process is not exact. Some of the "best" high school players do not pan out and then you get someone that comes out of nowhere and is a huge player. This goes just as well in the draft process as well. Tom Brady was not a 1st round pick but Ryan Leaf was. You have to trust in your coaches in all levels that their are able to see what the player is doing and able to improve on. Have them fit into your system and play nice with teammates. Not all players are fit for all systems. To bury your head in the sand and not look "outside" your area for players is foolish. Yes I will admit when a player comes from some distance there could be added issues like homesick, weather and culture shock. But I am sure the coaches ask all the right questions to these players. Bottom line is no matter where a player comes from if they truly want to be at the school they are at they will stay and do their best.

[Bison"FANatic"]

Need more Twin Cities Kids!! losing Luke sucks, (HE WAS A TOP 10 Minnesota ranked recruit!) we always should have 8-10 kids from the Twin Cities Metro each year, PERIOD>

(Yes we get 6-10 each year from TC/Minnesota)

Quota system seriously. Were you drunk last night and posting? Would you perform your sales job on a geographical quota? Well already sold to 5 people in South Fargo, there is this really good lead but I better head out to Warroad to make a sale so I get out state Minnesota covered. Or would you rank your leads and work them top down????

[bisonmike2]

I think it's been a while since we've gotten a recruit from Vermont. Get off your lazy ass coaches and start recruiting the northeast!

[EC8CH]

Is the op in the preposterous statements thread yet? It should be.

[EndZoneQB]

For real Lakes? I love you buddy, but c'mon man.

[HerdBot]

We always load up on Minnesota kids and it's our #1 state, so I am greatly confused. Almost 30% of our roster is from Minnesota

[56BISON73]

Need more Twin Cities Kids!! losing Luke sucks, (HE WAS A TOP 10 Minnesota ranked recruit!) we always should have 8-10 kids from the Twin Cities Metro each year, PERIOD>

(Yes we get 6-10 each year from TC/Minnesota)

:eeek::pan::rofl::facepalm:

[Christopher Moen]

Not sure if the coaches are worried about where a recruit went to school as much as the recruit is talented and is a fit for their system. NDSU's ability to find "hidden gems" is uncanny skill lacked by most programs.

[El_Chapo]

in our geographical area, Twin Cities football talent far exceeds the rest of said area's talent pool. how is this so hard for you knickleheads to understand ?

You're hate for el chapo is clouding your judgement!

keep bringing in the MWills, Billy Turners, Littlejohn, CJ Smith Crockett....etc

[yopaulie]

To be clear, El Chapo didn't create the actual title of the thread, calling for a quota system, correct? Was it was created by the admin to move this out of the standard recruiting thread? Are people ripping on him for the title? Or for the post about needing a stronger MN pipeline? Or just because it's El Chapo? (understandable) In this case, I actually agree with the sentiment of the continued importance of the MN pipeline, especially with U of M in a transition period with Claeys.

[MNLonghorn10]

Jose 2009-12!!!!
Say what you want...but Mohlers brilliance in the Kansas game is the reason why ndsu is where they're at. No win there, no snowball effect in confidence for a 2010 and no pissed off Bison team coming off an ewu heartbreak loss

[56BISON73]

Say what you want...but Mohlers brilliance in the Kansas game is the reason why ndsu is where they're at. No win there, no snowball effect in confidence for a 2010 and no pissed off Bison team coming off an ewu heartbreak loss

:omfg::eeek::eek::smh:

[Herd]

I had never seen Jose Mohler and the word brilliant used in the same sentence. Brilliant doesn't work as well as moderately serviceable. I don't think that Jose was playing defense in KS, which was the only part of the game that might be considered brilliant.

[MNLonghorn10]

I had never seen Jose Mohler and the word brilliant used in the same sentence. Brilliant doesn't work as well as moderately serviceable. I don't think that Jose was playing defense in KS, which was the only part of the game that might be considered brilliant.

how many points did the defense orchestrate? Jose doesnt win NDSU that kansas game, they are out of the playoffs and have zero reason to be motivated after the screw job.

[thebigund]

Jose Mohler - 10-22 1 int 0 td vs a Kansas team that would have lost to last years Wyoming team by 20
7048

[TransAmBison]

I bet Longhorn pissed himself laughing as he trolled that out.

[Bisonator98]

Say what you want...but Mohlers brilliance in the Kansas game is the reason why ndsu is where they're at. No win there, no snowball effect in confidence for a 2010 and no pissed off Bison team coming off an ewu heartbreak loss

:rofl::rofl::rofl:

[El_Chapo]

HEY Do you PUNKS wanna KEEP WINNING?

NDSU is succeeding because of TWIN CITIES STARS...(M WIll, Turner, Crockett, CJ Smith) We need to keep that PIPELINE GOING!

66

Zack Johnson

OG

6-4

329

Sr.

Apple Valley, Minn.

Eastview HS





68

Zack J. Johnson

OT

6-6

297

RFr.

Blaine, Minn.

Spring Lake Park HS





51

James Fisher

LS

6-2

212

Jr.

Bloomington, Minn.

Jefferson HS





33

Marquise Bridges

WR

5-11

176

RFr.

Brooklyn Park, Minn.

DeLaSalle HS





43

Kurt Mattox

LB

6-1

224

Jr.

Brooklyn Park, Minn.

Totino-Grace HS





63

Aaron Steidl

DT

6-2

291

So.

Carlos, Minn.

Alexandria Jefferson HS





92

Jack Darnell

DT

6-2

291

RFr.

Champlin, Minn.

Champlin Park HS





57

Bryan Carlton

DT

6-3

266

RFr.

Chanhassen, Minn.

Minnetonka HS





40

Dan Sargeant

FB

6-1

246

Jr.

Chisago City, Minn.

Chisago Lakes HS





60

Max Polson

C

6-1

307

Jr.

Coon Rapids, Minn.

Coon Rapids HS





95

Caleb Butler

DE

6-3

243

So.

Coon Rapids, Minn.

Blaine HS





18

Khayvon Hawkins

WR

6-0

199

So.

Crystal, Minn.

Robbinsdale Cooper HS





15

Daniel Polansky

WR

6-0

189

Jr.

Gatzke, Minn.

Grygla HS





39

Ben Ellefson

TE

6-3

247

RFr.

Hawley, Minn.

Hawley HS





35

Robbie Grimsley

SS

6-0

184

So.

Hutchinson, Minn.

Hutchinson HS





49

Matt Anderson

TE

6-4

245

RFr.

Lakeland, Minn.

Stillwater HS





4

Dimitri Williams

WR

5-11

190

So.

Lakeville, Minn.

Rosemount HS





73

Zack Ziemer

OG

6-4

294

Jr.

Lakeville, Minn.

Lakeville North HS





96

Greg Menard

DE

6-2

240

Jr.

Lakeville, Minn.

Lakeville North HS





17

James Hendricks

QB

6-1

201

RFr.

Laporte, Minn.

Bemidji HS





56

Peder Olson

LS/LB

6-0

218

So.

Maple Grove, Minn.

Maple Grove HS





72

Erik Olson

OT

6-5

268

Jr.

Maple Grove, Minn.

Maple Grove HS





77

Christian Triplett

C

6-3

299

So.

Maple Plain, Minn.

Delano HS





25

Chase Morlock

RB

6-0

219

Sr.

Moorhead, Minn.

Moorhead HS





37

Tre Fort

CB

5-8

178

RFr.

Moorhead, Minn.

Fargo Shanley HS





83

Dallas Freeman

WR

6-0

196

So.

St. Michael, Minn.

St. Michael-Albertville HS





37

Garrett Malstrom

RB

6-1

244

RFr.

Vergas, Minn.

Frazee-Vergas HS





98

Connor Hubbs

DT

6-1

274

RFr.

White Bear Lake, Minn.

White Bear Lake HS

[El_Chapo]

I rest my case, ndsu coaches have listened to me.

Great 2019 class from Minnesota/Twin Cities!

[El_Chapo]

I rest my case, ndsu coaches have listened to me.

Great 2019 class from Minnesota/Twin Cities!

Thank you Lance & Sproles ... not to mention some fine 2020 Twin Cities/Minnesota kids. Keep this Regional School pumping!